This article is the second in a two-part series dealing with “people problems” on projects.   In using the phrase “people problems,” we refer to various social and cultural barriers managers face on projects, such as resistance to change, departmental “silos,” lack of cooperation and teamwork, inadequate communication, lack of leadership support, and politics and infighting.  These types of problems often present the most daunting obstacles to project success.     

In our first article, we offered eleven practical preventive actions that the project manager may carry out during the planning phase of a project to avoid or at least mitigate the impact of these types of problems.  (Click here to view our original article)  

In this companion article we present options you can consider if “people problems” occur during the project and begin to impact negatively your progress, despite your best efforts to prevent them. 

Part II: Intervention Tools 

If “people problems” occur once a project is underway, there are seven specific intervention tools that have been used to get a project back on track.  These are:

  1. Guide for Personal Coaching

  2. Project Personnel Replacement

  3. Outside Facilitation

  4. Personality-Based Teambuilding Session

  5. Activity-Based Teambuilding Session

  6. Skills-Based Teambuilding Session

  7. Problem Solving-Based Teambuilding Session

The type of intervention tool used depends on the nature and severity of the people problems that threaten project success.  Each of these seven tools is explained below

Tool 1: Guide for Personal Coaching
Coaching is the tool of choice when the behavior or attitudes of a particular project member is causing problems that threaten project success.  The goal of this intervention is to help the project member become aware of how his/her actions are a hindrance to project completion.  The desirable outcome is that coaching will help change the behavior or attitudes of the project member who is hindering project success.  The person doing the coaching can be the project leader, the project sponsor, the project member’s supervisor, or even a respected colleague.  A variety of coaching techniques and tools can be used in this situation. 

Click here to read more about this tool.

Tool 2: Project Personnel Replacement
This type of action should only be used on rare occasions.  This tool is useful when the actions (or inactions), poor attitudes, lack of ability, or lack of performance of a particular project member is causing problems that threaten project success and several attempts to change the behavior have not been successful.  The purpose of this intervention is to remove someone from a project role so that the project team can quickly get over the problem and move forward on the project.  There are four factors that must be considered before taking this type of drastic action. 
Click here to read more about this tool.   

Tool 3:  Outside Facilitation
When the project is in jeopardy due to politics, lack of teamwork, or other “people” problems and when several attempts to deal with these issues have failed, an experienced third party, with no connections to the organization, could serve as an arbitrator and facilitator to help mediate conflicts to help projects move forward.  This “project rescue” focuses solely on people problems.  Using an outside facilitator is a fairly extreme remedy and should be used only with the most critical projects.  Although the approach of the facilitator may vary, this type of intervention has six general phases.
Click here to read more about this tool

Tool 4:  Personality-Based Teambuilding Session
This tool is used when a project team or sub-team is not performing well due to personality conflicts on the team.  The purpose of this intervention is to help team members better understand each other and thus learn how to work more effectively together.  Many personality conflicts on teams result from differences in how team members perceive, make decisions and interpret and react to the same set of stimuli.  Once these differences are understood, the team learns that many personality conflicts are due to misunderstandings and projections of motives that are not necessarily valid.  The team members can then agree on codes of conduct for communicating and working together more effectively. 
Click here to read more about this tool.

Tool 5:  Activity-Based Teambuilding Session
This tool can be applied when a project team is not performing well together due to a variety of symptoms, such as lack of trust, poor communication, or lack of teamwork.  The purpose of activity-based teambuilding is to help team members learn how to work together in a series of challenging outdoor group tasks and exercises.  Team members then apply the lessons learned to working together on the project.  Activity-based teambuilding can take place both indoors and outdoors.  Outdoors experiences include  “high” ropes courses, “low” ropes courses or various outdoor adventures.  All these exercises require groups to learn to work together to achieve success. 
Click here to read more about this tool. 

Tool 6:  Skills-Based Teambuilding Session
This tool is the approach of choice when a project team is not performing well together due to a lack of understanding of how teams operate and/or a lack of teamwork skills.  The purpose of this intervention is to teach team members specific teamwork skills and ground rules for operating more effectively together.  In skills-based teambuilding, team members participate in workshop sessions that require them to learn and practice specific teamwork skills (e.g., dealing with conflict, reaching group consensus, learning how to give criticism, or running effective team meetings).  These workshops should include skills development that can be applied immediately on the project.     
Click here to read more about this tool.

Tool 7:  Problem Solving-Based Teambuilding Session
Problem-solving teambuilding retreats are the most often used interventions on projects.  The purpose of this tool is to remove the team from its everyday setting and get the team to agree on the barriers they are having, analyze why they are occurring, and then take ownership of the problems by agreeing on actions they will take to get the project back on track.  This type of intervention is normally quite successful at getting project teams focused, aligned, and more productive.  Several steps must be followed when carrying out this type of intervention. 
Click here to read more about this tool.

Conclusion

The eleven preventative tools described in Part One of this article series can help project leaders prevent problems from occurring.  If these people problems still arise, despite the leaders’ best planning efforts, then the seven intervention action tools described above will help project leaders deal with the leadership, politics, teamwork, and resistance to change issues that typically drive up project costs, lengthen project schedules, and threaten successful project completion.   

© 2005 Cornelius & Associates
 

Back to February Index for Impact: Proven Concepts for High Performance
 
Click here to see an index of all articles

 

Home Teamwork Project Management Leadership Development Who We Are Our Speakers Our People Our Clients Our Products & Training Courses Articles What's New

 

 

 


Intervention Tool 1: 
Guide for Personal Coaching
 

Tool Name

Guide for Personal Coaching
 

When to Use

When the behaviors or attitudes of a particular project team member is causing problems that threaten project success.
 

Purpose

Change the behaviors or attitudes of a project team member who is causing problems that threaten project success.
 

Process Steps

The following information describes different coaching techniques.

Problem Solving Method:

  1. State the issue in a way that comes across as though there is a problem that must be solved (i.e., this is not a personal attack).

  2. Listen carefully.

  3. Get the person involved in coming up with ideas to solve the problem.

  4. Reach closure on a course of action.

  5. Follow-up.

Persuasion Method

  1. Get the person’s attention (appeal to a pet peeve or give an offer that can’t be refused).

  2. Make a specific suggestion.

  3. Show understanding for how difficult the suggestion might be to implement.

  4. Sell the benefits of the change.

  5. Ask for commitment.

Formal Coaching Model

  1. Set the stage by stating the purpose of the conversation, the benefits of having the conversation, and the process you would like to follow.

  2. Listen first to the reaction and ideas of the person you are coaching and then carefully summarize what they say and how they feel.

  3. Express the areas where you both agree and disagree.

  4. Work on the areas where you both disagree in order to come up with a plan for the future.

Time Investment

Anywhere from five minutes to thirty minutes.
 

Back to article

 

 

 

 

 

Intervention Tool 2:  Project Personnel Replacement
 

Tool Name

Project Personnel Replacement
 

When to Use

When the actions (or inactions), poor attitudes, or lack of ability of a particular project member is causing problems that threaten project success and several attempts to change the behavior have been successful.
 

Purpose

Remove someone from a project role so that the project team can quickly get over the problem and move forward.
 

Process Steps

There are four factors that must be considered before taking this type of drastic action:

  1. Project personnel should truly be a problem person that is hurting the goals of the project.

  2. Project leader has tried coaching and counseling and no improvements are shown by the project team member.

  3. The project sponsor has been involved and the sponsor has talked with the project team member’s supervisor about interventions that can be pursued.

  4. There is another person available that can step in for this project team member and can take over the project role.

Time Investment

Varies depending on situation
 

 Back to article

 

 

 

 

Intervention Tool 3:  Outside Facilitation
 

Tool Name

Outside Facilitation
 

When to Use

When the project is in jeopardy due to politics, lack of teamwork, or other “people” problems and when several attempts to deal with these issues have failed.   
 


Purpose

Use an experienced third party, with no connections to the organization, to serve as an arbitrator and facilitator to help overcome barriers and move the project forward.   

This is a form of a “project rescue” where the emphasis is solely on people problems.  Using an outside facilitator is a fairly extreme remedy and should only be used with the most critical projects. 

An outside facilitator may be used to help a single project team, or the facilitator may be used to help the project implementation team, steering team, or other critical project group that is not making progress due to leadership, politics, teamwork, or resistance to change issues.
 


Process Steps

The approach used will vary depending on the abilities and style of the facilitator.  The steps below outline a possible series of intervention steps:

  1. All parties agree that outside help is needed.

  2. All parties agree on the outside facilitator.

  3. Diagnosis is carried out by the outside facilitator.

  4. Ground rules are agreed upon through facilitation of a third party.

  5. The facilitator makes recommendations and these recommendations are carried out by the project team.

  6. The outside facilitator continues to coach and monitor, as needed, to ensure project success.


Time Investment

Varies with the type of problem faced and the type of intervention recommended by the facilitator.
 

Back to article

 

 

 

 

Intervention Tool 4:  Personality-Based Teambuilding Session
 
Tool Name

Personality-Based Teambuilding Session
 

When to Use

When a project team or sub-team is not performing well due to personality conflicts on the team.
 

Purpose

Help team members better understand each other, and thus learn how to work more effectively together.
 

Rationale

Many “personality conflicts” result from differences in how team members perceive, make decisions and interpret and react to the same set of stimuli.  Once these differences are understood, the team learns that many “personality conflicts” are due to misunderstandings and “projections” of motives that are not necessarily valid.  They then can agree on codes of conduct for communicating and working together more effectively.   

In addition to the above, the process of carrying out this intervention in a retreat setting often helps generate camaraderie and team spirit. 
 

Process Steps
  1. Team members fill out a personality inventory/assessment.

  2. The instruments are scored and interpreted by a facilitator.

  3. A one-day workshop/retreat is scheduled to review the results and learn about each person’s personality profile.

  4. During the workshop, the facilitator guides the team through a series of exercises to help participants understand the unique personality differences on the team.

  5. The facilitator helps the team agree on ground rules for respecting team member differences and ground rules for communicating and working together based on these differences.

Time Investment

Minimum is a half-day workshop; however, for best results a one-day workshop is recommended. 
 

Resources Click here to read a past article with more detailed information about teambuilding sessions.
 

Back to article

 

 

 

 

Intervention Tool 5: Activity-Based Teambuilding Session
 

Tool Name

Activity-Based Teambuilding Session

When to Use

When a project team is not performing well together due to any number of different symptoms (lack of trust, poor communication, lack of teamwork, etc.). 

Also can be used when a team is in a “rut” and would like an experience to help “energize” or reinvigorate the team.  Can also be used as an occasion to simply have fun together to improve morale.

Purpose

Help team members learn how to work together in a series of challenging outdoor group tasks and exercises.

Rationale

Lessons learned in experiential outdoor group tasks can then be transferred to the work setting to improve everyday team performance. 
 

Types of Exercises

Activity-based teambuilding can be carried out in a variety of settings, such as “high” ropes courses, “low” ropes courses or an outdoor adventure such as white water rafting, mountain climbing, or even a survival course or boot camp. 

All these exercises require groups to learn to work together to achieve success.

Note

It is important to custom design the experiential exercises around specific development needs of teams, such as group problem solving, risk-taking, trust, or paradigm breaking. 

Time Investment

These exercises can range from four to eight hours for a typical “ropes” course to two or more days for outdoor adventures.
 

Resources Click here to read a past article with more detailed information about teambuilding sessions.
 

Back to article

 

 

 

 

Intervention Tool 6:  Skills-Based Teambuilding Session
 

Tool Name

Skills-Based Teambuilding Session
 

When to Use

When a project team is not performing well together due to a lack of understanding of how teams operate and/or a lack of teamwork skills.
 

Purpose

Teach team members specific teamwork skills and ground rules for operating more effectively together.
 

Rationale

The underlying philosophy with the skill-building approach is that the most likely reason groups don’t work together well as a team is because they do not have the necessary skills.  Thus, the obvious first step in building better teams is to have teams practice using teamwork skills in facilitated workshop settings, increasing the likelihood they will use these skills in the actual work setting.    
 

Approach

In skills-based teambuilding, team members participate in workshop sessions that require them to learn and practice specific teamwork skills (e.g., dealing with conflict, reaching group consensus, learning how to give criticism, or running effective team meetings).  These workshops include skills that can be applied immediately in the workplace.   

The teambuilding aspect of this approach is maximized when intact teams participate together and make commitments to use these new tools to improve the way the team functions. 
 

Time Investment

The amount of time invested varies with the number of skills that need to be learned and the maturity level of the team.  For example, team meeting skills and group decision-making and group consensus tools can be taught in a half-day workshop.  Critical interpersonal skills such as giving and receiving feedback, dealing with criticism and conflict, listening, and teamwork styles can be taught in a two to three-day workshops.  Group problem solving tools usually can be taught in one to two days. 
 

Resources Click here to read a past article with more detailed information about teambuilding sessions.
 

Back to article

 

 

 

 

Intervention Tool 7:  Problem Solving-Based Teambuilding Session
 

Tool Name

Problem Solving-Based Teambuilding Session
 

When to Use

bullet

Project team needs a “jump start.”

bullet

Team is having trouble working together and getting things done.

bullet

Team members are not taking the time to work on the project.

bullet

Lack of cohesion or sense of purpose among the group.

bullet

Not making progress they should be making, i.e. goals and milestones not being met.

bullet

Team members are feeling overwhelmed.

bullet

Team members are frustrated because progress is not being made.

bullet

Not all team members are pulling their fair share of the weight.
 

Purpose

Remove the team from its everyday setting and get the team to agree on the barriers they are having, analyze why, and then take ownership in the problems by agreeing on actions they will take to get back on track.
 

Process Steps

During a one or two-day retreat, facilitate the team through the following steps:

  1. List the barriers that are facing the team.

  2. Prioritize the barriers and select the most important to work on.

  3. Analyze each barrier in subgroups by analyzing causes, root causes, and actions steps that can be taken to remove or mitigate the barrier.

  4. Reach commitment to move forward and execute the action steps.

  5. Assign responsibilities and timelines.

  6. Follow-up on progress in subsequent project team meetings.

Time Investment One or two-day retreat
 
Resources Click here to read a past article with more detailed information about teambuilding sessions.
 

Back to article